I did quite a bit of online research and came up with three models to choose from:
Honda Accord (of course)
Toyota Camry
Mazda 6
After driving the Honda, Martha and I were underwhelmed. Although it is a nice car, we both felt it was under powered. Martha even thought it looked just like our '95 Accord.
We then headed over to the Toyota dealership. Believe it or not, no salesman actually wanted to talk to us. One sales guy walked us out to the lot and had us look at a few Camrys. He didn't even have keys to let us inside the cars. But just looking through the windows, we saw how plain the inside looked. And we knew that this car wasn't for us.
Next up was the Mazda 6. As soon as we sat in one, we were blown away. Martha said immediately that this is the car she wants.
For the following two weeks, I gathered quotes from local Mazda dealerships. I played the dealers against each other, trying to have on under bid the next. After a while I got them all to pretty much the same price. One dealership offered $500 in free gas, and that's the one we went with.
So here it is, our new Mazda 6: